The honest comparison. How did alternative-investment platforms actually perform against the one thing a passive index-fund investor would have done instead? Fees and illiquidity included — this is what most reviews leave out.
Comparing an illiquid alt directly to a liquid index fund understates the real cost of the alt. Academic literature (Ang, Papanikolaou, Westerfield 2014) suggests an illiquidity premium of 2–8% annually to properly compensate for lockup periods. This calculator subtracts your chosen illiquidity penalty from the alt return to make the comparison apples-to-apples.
If you set the illiquidity penalty to 0%, you're comparing nominal returns only — which flatters most alts unfairly.
The S&P 500 has returned roughly 12% annualized over the past decade — well above its long-run ~10% average. Any alt returning less than that has, numerically, "lost" to the index over this specific period. That doesn't make alts useless. It means they're diversifiers, not replacements. The question to ask is whether your portfolio would be better off during the next decade's drawdown — which the S&P will eventually have.